Nvidia May Have Kept Graphics Cards Scarce to Protect Profits

Nvidia May Have Kept Graphics Cards Scarce to Protect Profits

Nvidia reportedly faced a flood of chip supplies as high prices drove cloud buyers elsewhere. Did it keep graphics cards scarce to protect profits?

An approaching “avalanche” of chip wafers and memory reportedly left Nvidia looking for buyers just as high hardware prices pushed major cloud providers toward other suppliers. The Wall Street Journal reported last week that, despite strong demand, the equipment had become too expensive even for those providers. Meanwhile, incoming supplies of wafers and memory, the core components used in its cards, threatened to exceed what Nvidia could readily absorb.

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang reportedly responded by expanding financing deals for smaller cloud providers and data center developers. Those arrangements were intended to bring in loyal customers whose purchases would help reduce the accumulating inventory.

That account led to speculation that Nvidia had pushed prices artificially high rather than lowering them as supplies grew. The source describes “artificial scarcity” as a familiar, legally dubious practice in which monopoly pricing helps companies exclude rivals and boost profits. Under this interpretation, Nvidia may have created the appearance of a chip shortage to support unusually high prices.

The source sees the report as supporting AI critic Ed Zitron’s claim that hardware “sitting in warehouses” accounts for approximately half of Nvidia’s chip sales. Zitron puts the value of that unused equipment at hundreds of billions of dollars.

Circular financing is another particularly thorny issue the source identifies within an AI industry already causing unease among economists. These arrangements send investment money through a cycle that ultimately returns it to Nvidia. That cycle, the report says, sends Nvidia’s share price soaring.

As hyperscalers compete to obtain Nvidia’s AI chips, the company has continued to face allegations of monopolistic behavior. By selling the shovels for the AI gold rush, Nvidia has made huge profits, and its customers have few alternatives.

The inventory problem came months before Huang was reportedly caught cheating on his wife with an alleged Chinese spy. The scandal led to his resignation, and the fallout could loosen Nvidia’s grip on the market.

Congress is already seeking to question Huang early next year, the source reports, and those hearings could bring further scrutiny of Nvidia’s questionable business practices. According to the same account, shares in Nvidia’s largest rivals climbed sharply last week following Huang’s announcement that he would leave the company with immediate effect. The report reads that as a sign investors want to diversify.

“This could turn what has effectively been a monopoly into a horse race again, as competitors rush to meet growing demand,” Bret Greenstein, chief AI officer at consultancy West Monroe, said to the Canadian Press. “Nvidia did not create that demand, and a shift in this part of the market could ultimately diversify the supply chain, create more choice for customers and strengthen the broader AI industry in the years ahead.”

The Genius Geek
The Genius Geek

The Weekly Geek

Don't miss a thing: get our top stories in a weekly roundup.