Astronomers Spot Possible Supermassive Neutron Star Defying Simulations

Astronomers Spot Possible Supermassive Neutron Star Defying Simulations

Researchers in China may have found a massive neutron star orbiting a red giant, one that defied 300,000 simulations. Published in Science Advances.

Three hundred thousand simulations, and not one of them could build this system. That’s the headline result from a team of researchers in China who think they’ve found an unseen companion hiding next to a red giant star. The companion looks like a neutron star at the very top of what’s thought to be physically possible, but its mass and its orbit are both stubbornly hard to explain.

The findings are published as a study in the journal Science Advances. Using observations from the LAMOST telescope and the APOGEE observatory, the team inferred that the red giant has a hidden binary partner. The pair is designated J0008+0128, and the partner is no ordinary star. It appears to be an ultra-compact object.

Neutron stars are what’s left when a much more massive star explodes in a supernova and only its extremely dense core survives. They’re roughly the size of a human city, yet a single tablespoon of the material would weigh more than a billion tons.

A typical neutron star weighs around 1.4 times the mass of our Sun, and none discovered so far has topped 2.5 solar masses. The unseen companion in J0008+0128 could weigh up to 2.8. The team’s best estimate is lower, more likely around 2.2, but even that puts the object at the edge of what astronomers think is possible, and it’s large enough to confound their attempts to explain it.

Mass isn’t the only oddity. According to Phys.org, the two objects take about 3.3 years to complete an orbit, which means they’re quite far apart. Each also follows an unusually circular path, which is surprising given both that distance and the violent history a neutron star implies.

The distance matters because of how heavier neutron stars usually get that way: their gravity strips material off a binary companion. The stars in J0008+0128 are too far apart for that to work. The astronomers ran 300,000 simulations, and not a single one reproduced the conditions they were seeing, including the neutron star’s mass and orbit.

The team is weighing several alternatives. The suspected neutron star might have formed when two white dwarfs, which are compact but less extremely dense stellar remnants, collided. Or there may be a third star in the system that nobody is seeing, perhaps two more typical neutron stars in a tight orbit. The last option is that the object is a tiny black hole with a mass never seen before.

Scott Ransom, an astronomer at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory who wasn’t involved in the study, told Scientific American: “Astrophysically, there’s no reason why you can’t have black holes that small; it’s just that we don’t see any of them in our galaxy. What [the orbit’s shape] probably means is that the birth of that neutron star or black hole was not especially violent.”

Ransom explains that a neutron star’s birth is more violent than a black hole’s, which makes the newborn object more likely to careen out of a tidy orbit. “So the fact that the orbit is more circular might be evidence that this is a black hole and not a neutron star,” he added.

For now, then, J0008+0128 isn’t a confirmed record-breaking neutron star. It’s an unseen object whose identity is still open, in a system that none of the 300,000 simulations could produce.

The Genius Geek
The Genius Geek

The Weekly Geek

Don't miss a thing: get our top stories in a weekly roundup.